Understanding Your True Reach: The Science Behind Congregation Engagement

Have you ever wondered if your church's attendance numbers tell the whole story? I remember walking into the office on Monday morning and staring at our 'weekend at a glance' dashboard. The numbers looked good – 153,000 average weekly attendance between online and in-person services. But something was nagging at me.

Sure, attendance matters. But what if we're missing something more meaningful? This question led us down a path that transformed how we understood and measured engagement at Gateway. Today, I want to share what we learned about measuring true reach – and why it matters more than ever for your church in 2025.

Beyond the Sunday Count

Here's a surprising truth: Your church's impact is likely much bigger (or sometimes smaller) than your attendance numbers suggest. Let me explain.

We all know that 2020 changed the church forever. As my Catholic friends liked to call out, it allowed Christians to experience a eucharistic free faith. For us Protestants, our parallel was the rejection of the assembly of believers. We no longer needed to be in person to 'attend' church. So, let's take a minute to rewind things and see what new foundation we are building our churches upon.

As all churches did during the pandemic, we faced a massive challenge. With traditional attendance metrics disrupted, we needed new ways to understand how we were reaching people. We discovered that while some metrics went down, others unexpectedly rose. For instance, when we implemented a personalized text message campaign, we reached over 100,000 people—with an astounding 60% response rate within 48 hours.

This taught us a valuable lesson: engagement isn't just about who's in the room – it's about who's being impacted by your ministry across all touch points.

Three Dimensions of True Reach

Think of your church's reach like a 3D image instead of a flat photograph. Here are the key dimensions you should be measuring:

1. Physical Engagement

   • Sunday attendance (both services and classes)

   • Small group participation

   • Volunteer involvement

   • Event attendance

2. Digital Engagement

   • Online service views (but look at watch time, not just views)

   • Social media interaction (meaningful engagement, not just likes)

   • Email open rates and click-through rates

   • Website activity (time on page, not just page views)

3. Ministry Engagement

   • Prayer requests

   • Giving patterns

   • Ministry participation

   • Next steps taken (baptisms, memberships, etc.)

The Engagement Discovery

We made an interesting discovery when we started measuring all three dimensions. While our Sunday attendance showed one picture, our actual reach was significantly different when we accounted for all touch points. For example, when we shifted our email strategy to focus on personalization (the right message, to the right person, at the right time, in the right channel (e.g., text, email, social media, etc.), our engagement rates doubled – from 40% to 80% open rates. This wasn't just about better numbers. These improved metrics translated into real ministry impact: more people connected to small groups, increased volunteer participation, and stronger discipleship journeys.

Making It Work for Your Church

Whether your church has 100 or 10,000 members, you can start measuring true reach today. Here's how:

1. Start With What You Have

   • List all your current touch points with your congregation

   • Document your current metrics for each

   • Identify gaps in your measurement

2. Focus on Trends, Not Just Numbers

   • Track month-over-month changes

   • Look for patterns in engagement

   • Pay attention to seasonal variations

3. Measure What Matters

   • Don't track numbers just for numbers' sake

   • Focus on metrics that indicate spiritual growth

   • Look for correlations between different types of engagement

Action Steps for This Week:

1. Audit your current measurement systems - what are you tracking now?

2. Identify at least one new engagement metric you can start measuring

3. Set up a simple spreadsheet or dashboard to track all three dimensions

4. Schedule a monthly review of these metrics with your leadership team

The Bottom Line

Remember, the goal isn't just more or better numbers – it's better ministry.

"Technology is an accelerant for ministry." - Tyler Vance, Life.Church

The same is true for metrics. When we measure the more impactful things, we can make better decisions about how to serve our people and advance God's kingdom.

Want to dive deeper? Check out our blog on 5 Essential Church Metrics You Need to Track in 2025 as a quick way to get started. Next week, we'll explore digital ministry metrics that drive real-world impact and show you how to turn online engagement into real-world ministry impact.

Do you have questions or want to share your insights? Reply to this email—I'd love to hear your thoughts!

Michael Visser

Co-founder, Threefold Solutions

P.S. We assist with coaching, training, strategy, and support.

#1: Need help with implementation? Reach out to us at info@threefold.solutions or contact us here.

#2: Want to learn more? Subscribe to our YouTube Channel.

#3: Stay in the know with our weekly newsletter, The Fold. Each week we discuss topics on church growth and management, volunteer and staff engagement, leadership development, and more.